top of page

Indian Toy Manufacturing: Challenges, Opportunities, and Future Prospects

Kit Chau
A woman in traditional Indian attire works diligently at a long table in a bright, spacious factory setting. She is painting or assembling small wooden toys, including colorful animal figures. In the background, other workers can be seen at similar workstations, and stacks of cardboard boxes line the walls, suggesting a bustling toy manufacturing facility. The image captures the essence of India's growing toy industry, showcasing skilled craftsmanship and modern production methods.

The reality of India's toy manufacturing sector presents a concerning picture. The domestic industry commands just 20% of the local market, while Chinese imports dominate the remaining 80%. While the market is projected to reach USD 3 billion by 2028, 75% of manufacturers remain small, struggling micro units.

India's toy-making heritage dates back to the Indus Valley Civilization. The current state of the manufacturing sector faces significant challenges. Three million workers, predominantly women, struggle with outdated technology and quality control issues. International competition has made survival increasingly difficult.

This analysis explores the factors behind the toy manufacturing sector's ongoing challenges. Despite government support through import duty increases from 20% to 60%, core issues persist. The journey toward manufacturing self-reliance remains challenging, with fundamental obstacles continuing to restrict the sector's growth potential.


The Struggling State of Indian Toy Manufacturing

Indian toy manufacturing grapples with a mere 0.3% share in global toy exports. This stands in stark contrast to China's commanding 80% market dominance. The domestic market value remains at USD 3 billion - a modest fraction of the USD 108 billion global market.


Declining market share despite government support

The sector continues to decline with 60% of India's 4,000 toy manufacturers remaining unorganized. These manufacturers lack modern capabilities and resources to invest in essential equipment and technology. The situation is exacerbated as 75% operate as micro units. They lack the capital to invest in machines that meet stringent quality standards.


Poor quality control and safety standards

Quality control issues manifest in multiple ways:


  • Toys contain hazardous materials like polyvinyl chloride (PVC) with harmful chemicals including phthalates, lead, and cadmium.

  • The market is saturated with small parts and poorly constructed toys.


India faces a significant shortage of certified testing facilities that meet global quality standards.

Quality control deficiencies disproportionately affect children from lower-income segments, who frequently experience health issues from substandard toys. The absence of a dedicated toy design institute in the country hampers safety enhancements and innovative developments.


Inability to compete with global players

Multiple structural weaknesses create competitive disadvantages. The industry must import most raw materials and machines from China and other Asian countries, including basic materials such as fabric for plush toys. Additionally, the sector experiences a significant deficit in engineering capabilities, particularly in 3D product prototyping, which is essential for modern toy production.

The situation appears more challenging as Indian manufacturing focuses primarily on manual and traditional toys, which represent only 16% of global toy sales. Despite government initiatives like increasing import duty from 60% to 70%, small manufacturers continue to struggle, particularly in electronic and battery-operated toy segments. Elevated import duties on machinery create additional barriers to modernizing production capabilities.


Critical Infrastructure and Technology Gaps

The Indian toy manufacturing sector confronts significant technological challenges. 90% of the market remains unorganized, with manufacturing units utilizing outdated methods that restrict production capabilities and quality standards.


Outdated manufacturing facilities

The manufacturing landscape faces fundamental infrastructure challenges:


  • Insufficient end-to-end manufacturing facilities

  • Inadequate testing laboratories

  • Limited toy parks and clusters

  • Suboptimal logistics support


Small manufacturers struggle to overcome these obstacles due to the 34% import duty on equipment, impeding modern machinery acquisition. This challenge is particularly acute since 75% operate as micro units and 22% function as small and medium enterprises.


Lack of R&D investment

R&D statistics reveal concerning trends. Only 12% of MSME toy manufacturers maintain in-house design studios with trained designers. This deficiency in precision tooling capabilities forces manufacturers to rely on imports.

The absence of toy-specific Common Facility Centers, which should provide essential services like raw materials, machinery, skill training, and design studios under one roof, exacerbates the R&D crisis. This hampers the sector's ability to develop innovative products and competitive designs.


Limited access to modern technology

Technical deficiencies become evident in specific areas. Indian manufacturers require engineering expertise in 3D product prototyping. Companies planning to establish production facilities encounter significant delays. Contractor selection requires up to 18 months while new factory construction demands three years.

Most manufacturers struggle to implement advanced technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), augmented reality (AR), and virtual reality (VR). This technological gap significantly impacts the electronic toy segment. The industry's dependence on Chinese components at competitive global prices creates additional market challenges.

The scarcity of trained toy designers capable of creating globally competitive designs highlights the depth of this crisis. The country lacks a professional ecosystem of toy designers and developers commonly found in established markets. Currently, young professionals do not view toymaking as a mainstream career path.


Workforce and Skill Development Challenges

The shortage of skilled workforce continues to impede India's toy manufacturing sector. The sector remains heavily dependent on labor-intensive production. Industry analysis shows that every USD 100 million investment generates 20,000 direct and 8,000 indirect jobs. However, the scarcity of skilled workers hampers growth potential.


Shortage of skilled labor

Design expertise represents the most critical challenge. The country has no dedicated toy design institute. Finding professionals capable of creating globally competitive designs proves challenging. This gap becomes particularly evident in specialized areas like mold making and product development.

The workforce faces multiple challenges:


  • 35% of workers in tier-1 factories earn below basic living wage standards

  • The labor cost advantage of USD 1.70 per hour versus China's USD 5.80 remains underutilized

  • 7 million artisans require immediate reskilling to meet industry standards


Inadequate training programs

The training infrastructure demonstrates significant inadequacies. Limited industry-academia partnerships create substantial gaps between designers and mold makers. Manufacturers resort to local skill pools, restricting innovation and quality enhancement opportunities.

The situation worsens as craftsmen struggle to adapt to market trends and international competition. While the Koppal Toy Cluster's skill development center offers promise, these initiatives remain too limited and fragmented to benefit the sector comprehensively.


High employee turnover

Low compensation and suboptimal working conditions lead to significant workforce instability. Gender disparities and inadequate grievance mechanisms contribute to workplace volatility. Labor contractors increase vulnerability to workers' rights violations. Contract workers frequently operate without social security benefits.

The challenge intensifies as toy manufacturing requires flexible staffing to accommodate rapidly changing product demands. For example, movie-themed toys experience sharp demand fluctuations and require diverse skill sets for each product. Labor regulations compound the issue by limiting hiring and firing flexibility once companies exceed certain size thresholds. This regulatory environment forces most units to maintain smaller operations.


Supply Chain Vulnerabilities

Raw material procurement presents a significant obstacle for India's toy manufacturing sector. The nation's raw material imports significantly surpass finished toy imports. Glass eyes for dolls, beads, and imitation stones contribute USD 137.2 million to import costs. This statistic underscores the country's substantial reliance on foreign materials.


Heavy dependence on imported raw materials

The industry encounters considerable risks due to material deficiencies across multiple categories:


  • Electronic components for battery-operated toys

  • Fabric essentials for soft toy production

  • Glass eyes for dolls and decorative elements

  • Beads and imitation stones for toy embellishments

  • Various types of specialized plastics

  • Electric motors and remote control apparatus

Production costs reveal a 40% differential compared to Chinese competitors, though this gap has narrowed to 20% recently. The situation deteriorates when importers exploit regulatory gaps, importing unbranded toys in knocked-down condition while paying merely 20% import duty.


Fragmented supplier network

The supplier landscape remains highly dispersed, with 90% of the market functioning in an unorganized manner. This fragmentation encompasses more than 4,000 MSME enterprises. Such scattered operations result in supply chain inefficiencies. Limited resources and innovation constraints in design, development, and equipment impede growth.


Poor logistics infrastructure

While logistics plays a vital role in trade and commerce, it faces considerable challenges. 66% of freight movement depends exclusively on road transportation. This creates supply chain bottlenecks. Manufacturers struggle with specialized functions beyond basic transportation.

These challenges manifest in various ways. Polymer costs exceed Chinese rates by 10% for domestic production. The cost of finance and lease rent reaches approximately double compared to Chinese manufacturers. Packaging constitutes 20% of toy costs, further complicating supply chain dynamics.

Government initiatives demonstrate potential through the allocation of five lakh hectares of land for industrial development and establishment of Special Economic Zones. However, small manufacturers continue facing fundamental supply chain challenges, struggling to maintain consistent production schedules and meet market demands.


Policy Implementation Failures

Quality control implementation in Indian toy manufacturing encounters substantial obstacles. The Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) certification process creates significant challenges. The Ministry of Commerce and Industry's Toy Quality Control Order 2020 mandates strict compliance requirements that many manufacturers find difficult to navigate.


Ineffective quality control measures

Manufacturers struggle with the BIS certification process complexity. Essential requirements include:


  • Safety aspects related to mechanical and physical properties

  • Flammability testing standards

  • Migration testing of certain elements

  • Requirements for swings, slides, and activity toys

  • Safety standards for electric toys


Traditional toy-making clusters like Channapatna in Karnataka's small manufacturers encounter severe pressure from certification requirements. The January 2021 certification deadline proved catastrophic. Artisans possessing century-old expertise experienced significant setbacks.


Complex regulatory environment

The regulatory landscape presents a labyrinth of challenges. Manufacturers must navigate 370 quality control orders across sectors of varying sizes. Each product category and manufacturing facility requires separate licenses, amplifying the process complexity.

The certification process encompasses multiple phases. Beginning with scope determination and pre-application preparation, manufacturers must provide comprehensive documentation. They need to address follow-up inquiries and coordinate with visiting BIS officials. This process becomes particularly challenging for manufacturers operating outside India.


Limited financial support

Financial limitations severely impact the sector's growth trajectory. Government support mechanisms demonstrate significant gaps, as 90% of the market operates without organization. Small toy manufacturers constitute 60% of India's 4,000 toy manufacturers. These entities lack sufficient resources for investing in cutting-edge technology and crucial equipment.

Manufacturers encounter multiple financial requirements:


  1. Investment in testing facilities

  2. Certification costs for each product type

  3. Regular quality control maintenance expenses


Micro-scale units face heightened challenges. The BIS permitted these units to operate without testing facilities for one year, subsequently extended to three years. However, fundamental financial challenges persist. Traditional craftsmen find these certifications unaffordable due to regulatory complexity and insufficient financial support.

Implementation failures manifest in various ways. Quality control measures create insurmountable barriers for small manufacturers despite well-intentioned objectives. Complex regulations result in extended timelines and elevated costs. Support mechanisms fail to address the sector's fundamental requirements, compelling numerous manufacturers to cease operations rather than achieve compliance.


Environmental and Sustainability Concerns

Plastic waste emerges as a critical environmental threat in Indian toy manufacturing. The sector consumes 40 tons of plastic per USD 1 million in revenue. This industry's environmental impact raises significant concerns regarding ecosystem effects.


High plastic waste generation

Toy manufacturing's plastic waste statistics reveal concerning figures. 90% of market toys contain plastic components. These materials persist in ecosystems for up to 500 years. The situation appears more severe as nearly 80% of all toys end up in landfills, incinerators, or oceans. They constitute approximately 6% of landfill plastics.

The waste management crisis intensifies because:

  • More than 125 out of 419 chemicals in toy materials pose potential health risks

  • Plastic toys contain heavy metals including cadmium and lead

  • Material complexity significantly impedes recycling efforts


Energy inefficient operations

Manufacturing processes exhibit significant energy inefficiencies. The sector continues to employ outdated practices and antiquated manufacturing methods. Organizations demonstrate inadequate compliance with the Energy Conservation Act. A majority of manufacturers have yet to implement energy-efficient technologies and production aids.

The industry's carbon footprint continues its upward trajectory. Plastic production for toys is projected to contribute 13% of total global emissions by 2050. The situation appears more critical considering plastic's perpetual greenhouse gas emissions, both in atmospheric and submarine environments.


Non-compliance with global standards

The sector's environmental compliance reveals substantial deficiencies. Approximately 30% of plastic toys fail to meet safety standards regarding acceptable levels of phthalates and heavy metals. Rural regions face heightened challenges. Local residents frequently dispose of and incinerate toy waste in residential backyards or near riverbanks, releasing pollutants that impact surrounding areas.

Prior to recent regulatory implementation, 67% of toys marketed in India failed all safety and standard tests. The absence of modern waste management facilities exacerbates these issues. This phenomenon occurs more frequently in developing regions lacking proper waste management infrastructure. Pollutants can traverse significant distances via water currents, impacting coastal waters.

The toy industry encounters numerous obstacles in achieving environmental responsibility. Manufacturers demonstrate limited understanding of Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR). Additionally, existing recycling infrastructure proves inadequate for processing specific toy materials. Encouraging proper consumer disposal practices remains challenging without effective awareness initiatives.

Positive developments have emerged as manufacturers embrace eco-friendly practices. The industry shows movement toward sustainable materials including bamboo, recycled plastics, and organic fabrics. Indian craftsmanship experiences revitalization with environmental consciousness. However, these measures prove insufficient in addressing the substantial environmental challenges posed by current practices.


Conclusion

Indian toy manufacturing requires immediate attention. While government initiatives aim to boost domestic production, systemic challenges persist across multiple fronts. The industry faces difficulties with quality control, outdated technology, and skill deficiencies. Environmental concerns raise additional questions regarding sustainability.

Small manufacturers face particular hardships. BIS certification requirements and financial constraints have forced numerous traditional craftsmen to cease operations. The heavy reliance on imported raw materials creates cost disadvantages against global competitors.

The path forward presents significant challenges. Despite increased import duties and policy modifications, domestic industry maintains only 20% market share. Foreign manufacturers, predominantly from China, control the remaining 80%, indicating ineffective competition. Industry stakeholders seek perspectives and solutions for this struggling sector.

Indian toy manufacturing risks continued regression behind global standards without substantial improvements in technology, workforce training, and supply chain management. The industry requires comprehensive restructuring, rather than superficial policy adjustments, to achieve global competitiveness.


FAQs

Q1. What is the current state of the Indian toy manufacturing industry? The domestic toy manufacturing sector demonstrates significant challenges, commanding merely 20% of the local market share while import dependency accounts for 80%. The industry structure remains predominantly unorganized, with 75% comprising micro-enterprises that encounter substantial hurdles in maintaining quality standards, implementing technological advancements, and meeting international competition.


Q2. What are the main challenges faced by Indian toy manufacturers? The sector confronts multiple obstacles, including obsolete production facilities, insufficient research and development investments, workforce skill gaps, substantial reliance on imported materials, complex regulatory frameworks, and environmental issues related to plastic waste management.


Q3. How does the Indian toy industry compare to global competitors? The sector demonstrates considerable gaps when compared to international competitors, particularly China. While India's contribution to global toy exports remains at 0.3%, China dominates with 80% market share. Domestic manufacturers encounter elevated production expenses, restricted access to contemporary technologies, and limited competitiveness in electronic and battery-operated toy categories.


Q4. What efforts are being made to improve the Indian toy manufacturing sector? Governmental interventions include import duty escalation, mandatory BIS certification implementation, and financial assistance programs. However, these initiatives demonstrate limited effectiveness due to execution challenges and fundamental industry weaknesses.


Q5. What are the environmental concerns associated with toy manufacturing in India? Environmental challenges in the sector encompass extensive plastic waste generation, with 90% of products incorporating plastic components. The industry exhibits energy-inefficient operations and inadequate adherence to international environmental protocols. The sector demonstrates an increasing necessity for sustainable manufacturing practices and efficient waste management systems.



Comments


GSNMC Company Logo

ABOUT US

GSNMC Co. Limited stands as a preeminent toy manufacturer in the plastic products and toys industries, specializing in a diverse portfolio encompassing toys, plastic goods, and consumer products. With a strong emphasis on international clientele, the company excels in providing an array of critical services. These include state-of-the-art manufacturing capabilities (offering both OEM and ODM solutions), comprehensive product sourcing, innovative product design, and meticulous quality inspection processes. GSNMC's multifaceted approach positions it as a one-stop solution for businesses seeking expertise in plastic product and toy development and production, ensuring high standards of quality and innovation for global markets. Whether you need custom doll manufacturers or are looking to create custom plastic toys, action figures, or promotional products, our team has the expertise to bring your vision to life.

Hong Kong Logo
HK Office

Address: Unit 17, 12/F, Block B, Merit Industrial Centre, 94 To Kwa Wan Road, Kowloon, Hong Kong.

Tel: +86 13510605173

Email: office@gsnmc.com

China Logo
China Office

Address: Room 401, Building 4, Xinzhongtai Innovation Park, No. 1 Caiyun Road, Jixiang Community, Longcheng Street, Longgang District, Shenzhen City, Guangdong Province, People Republic of China.

Tel: +86 13510605173

Email: office@gsnmc.com

© 2024 by GSNMC Co. Limited 

  • LinkedIn
bottom of page